Scott Jennings Hits 32% After Secret Meetings With Susie Wiles

---

Why Is Scott Jennings Surging to 32% as Trump's Next Press Secretary?

Scott Jennings doubled his implied probability in the "Who will be Trump's next Press Secretary?" market, rising from 16% to 32% in three days after reports placed the CNN commentator at private dinners with Chief of Staff Susie Wiles. Jennings, 48, has reportedly been holding private meetings with Wiles, including a dinner at a Washington steakhouse that CNN described as arranged at the White House's request. Multiple staffers told the outlet they believe Wiles is backing him.

The move accelerated after two catalysts landed almost simultaneously: former frontrunner Alina Habba publicly denied she was pursuing the role, posting "I'm not in the running for any job," and Jennings made a conspicuous public defense of Trump aide Natalie Harp, calling Democratic Senator Jon Ossoff a "sucker punching coward" after Ossoff criticized her. Observers interpreted the Harp defense as a deliberate audition for the president's attention.

---

Scott Jennings vs. the Field: Where Does He Stand in the Press Secretary Race?

Jennings' 32% makes him the market leader, but the race is far from settled. His price sits at 36% on Kalshi and 27% on Polymarket, a nine-point spread across platforms that reflects genuine uncertainty about what Trump will ultimately do. His period low was just 8%, meaning the current price represents a 24-percentage-point swing from the bottom.

Habba's collapse was the single biggest structural shift. She was trading above 41% on Kalshi as recently as Wednesday before her denial cratered her contract to roughly 7%. That freed up an enormous amount of implied probability to redistribute across the field. Jennings captured the largest share, but he is far from a consensus pick.

Prediction-market view

Live prices, venue by venue

Compare the latest YES price at each venue. Check market rules, liquidity, and fees before trading.

Scott Jennings

Consensus YES price across 3 venues

15%average

PolymarketBest YES price14.7¢Kalshi16¢Predict.fun16.7¢

Danielle Alvarez

Consensus YES price across 1 venues

8%average

KalshiBest YES price9¢

No new person

Consensus YES price across 1 venues

5%average

KalshiBest YES price8.1¢

Steven Cheung

Consensus YES price across 1 venues

1%average

KalshiBest YES price1.7¢

Current new-user offer · Kalshi

Get a $35 trading bonusCode PRED35

New users only. Eligibility restrictions and terms apply.

View current offer

Natalie Harp, Trump's executive assistant, has also entered the conversation after CNN reported that Trump "has joked to advisers that maybe he would tap his executive assistant for the role." Whether that constitutes a serious candidacy or Trump's characteristic musing remains unclear, but it introduces a wildcard that limits Jennings' ceiling.

---

What Makes Scott Jennings a Credible Pick for White House Press Secretary?

The bull case for Jennings rests on three pillars: television fluency, institutional knowledge, and the backing of the most powerful gatekeeper in Trump's West Wing.

Jennings has spent years as CNN's most combative conservative voice, defending the administration in hostile territory night after night. That combat-tested media presence is exactly what the White House needs heading into a midterm environment where Democrats hold an eight-point lead on the generic congressional ballot and Republicans risk losing both chambers. A senior White House official told CNN simply: "He's competent and good on TV."

His resume goes beyond punditry. Jennings served as White House Deputy Director of Political Affairs under George W. Bush and spent decades as a senior adviser to Mitch McConnell's political operation. He understands press dynamics from both sides of the podium. The Wiles connection may be decisive: reports describe her as his champion inside the building, the kind of internal advocate that often determines who gets hired in a Trump White House where competing factions vie for influence.

---

The Case Against Scott Jennings: What Could the Market Be Getting Wrong?

The strongest bear case is simple: Trump does not typically hire people whose loyalty arc includes a wobble. Jennings publicly criticized Trump after January 6, and his years-long association with McConnell (a figure Trump has openly despised) make him radioactive to a faction of MAGA loyalists who hold veto power over personnel decisions.

The Daily Beast reports that some Trump allies consider Jennings' past remarks "unforgivable" and are actively working to block his appointment. This is not background noise. Trump has reversed course on personnel decisions before when his base objects loudly enough, and the MAGA media ecosystem can generate enormous pressure against perceived outsiders.

There is also the Natalie Harp factor. Trump has a well-documented preference for promoting people already in his orbit over importing talent from cable news green rooms. Harp travels with the president daily, is frequently photographed exiting Marine One alongside him, and has a salary that would jump from $150,000 to $195,200 in the Press Secretary role. If Trump's "jokes" about promoting her reflect genuine interest, Jennings' Wiles dinners may not matter.

At 32%, the market is pricing Jennings as roughly a one-in-three shot. That feels about right given the crosscurrents: strong institutional backing from Wiles on one side, MAGA resistance and Trump's unpredictable decision-making on the other. The market resolves December 31, 2026, leaving months of potential reversals. Anyone trading this contract should monitor whether MAGA opposition escalates or quiets down, and whether Harp's candidacy graduates from presidential musings to a formal push. For the latest pricing and a full breakdown of all candidates, visit the Trump's next Press Secretary odds page.